North Fork Dream Home: $2,300,000 waterfront house on Shelter Island

54 Westmoreland Dr
Escape the crowds to your own private waterfront compound at 54 Westmoreland Drive on Shelter Island.

With its own swimming pool, private beach and private deepwater dock, this nearly 3,400-square-foot property is sure to be popular with water lovers.

“It’s great for water skiing, it’s wonderful for swimming, boating, and fishing,” said Associate Real Estate Broker Susan Cincotta of Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty. “If you want to go out to the open water, it’s right there.”

At four feet, the water is deeper there then most of Westneck Bay, which is three and a half feet at low tide. An expansive waterside inground swimming pool creates a beautiful outdoor entertainment area with a deck made of Mexican ceramic tile. The private deepwater dock is boat ready and offers easy access to open water.

At 1.1 acres the five bedroom, four bathroom house sits on a larger than normal size property that faces Westneck Bay. The open floor plan includes cathedral ceilings, numerous skylights, a fireplace and a gameroom.

“It’s great for a family because there are three distinct guest wings,” Cincotta said. “The second floor is dedicated to the master suite that includes a large bathroom with a steamroom, a walk-in closet and water views.”

The rest of the bedrooms also offer plenty of privacy with separate guest wings, including a guest suite that has its own bathroom. The property is located on a quiet cul-de-sac away from through traffic and facing preserved land. Other amenities include the gameroom with its own separate entrance, an eat-in kitchen and laundryroom.

Yet despite its size, this house is well thought out in its design with easy access and views, Cincotta said.

“The kitchen is very open and centrally-located so everyone can meet in the kitchen and dining area,” Cincotta said. “There’s a door to the waterside deck from there and another door to the front patio. You’re in the thick of things, but you can still see the kids in the pool, you can look at the water, you’re not stuck in the kitchen, it’s perfectly situated.”

See more photos below:

$2,300,000
54 Westmoreland Dr, Shelter Island
5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms
3,398 square feet
Susan Cincotta
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
54 Westmoreland Dr
Great Value. Deep Water Dock Has 6″ At Low Tide On Oversized 1.1 Landscaped Acres. Waterside Fenced Pool With Lots Of Deck For Entertaining. The Beach House Is Open And Airy With Soaring Ceilings + Walls Of Windows On Waterside, 3 Separate Guest Wings Surround The Spacious Kitchen, Dining, Den + Living Room With A Full Finished Basement Boasting Game/Media Room, + Bath.
See This Property »